I’m a lemmy.zip user and I moderate two communities. One of them is new and another has about 350 subscribers. A recent issue related to .zip weighs too heavily on me to be able to stay on the instance.

I’ve had PieFed on my radar for a while now, as evidenced by the registration date of this account, but because moving community subscribers is hard and requires regular reminders, I postponed their migration. To this end, it’s worth noting that PieFed currently allows to pull some old posts if you migrate, making it superior to Lemmy for moving a community.

Being fresh off of what I’m convinced are instances of brigading of my community, I also appreciate Rimu’s focus on voting and activity patterns, as well as what looks like attempts to offer mod tools that aid with those and other tasks.

So the PieFed software feels like an obvious choice. What I’m struggling with is picking an instance. Aside from fedinsfw, .social is the only instance that has enough monthly active users, 1,500, to compete with some of the bigger Lemmy instances. Excluding these two, the others get around 300 monthly at best. The latest version of PieFed, 1.8, is from a month ago, but many are running on outdated versions. This is a problem because I like PieFed’s active pace of development. Even my own bug report and a wording suggestion from just recently were quickly addressed. Outdated versions wouldn’t be able to make use of these improvements.

Going instance by instance, here’s my thought process:

  • Looking at the numbers, piefed.social is the way to go. However, given that my previous two instances involved serious disagreements with the staff, I don’t want to run into a situation where I’m at odds with Rimu, as it could also close the door to my contributions to PieFed as a whole, either by my choice or by Rimu’s.

  • piefed.zip and piefed.world are not acceptable, as I’ve already been through those.

  • piefed.ca is the next best based on its number of users, but it’s on PieFed 1.7 and I haven’t been able to reach the admins over the past two days. One criterion I’m looking for after being brigaded is being able to urgently get in touch with an admin, so responsiveness matters.

  • feddit.online is up to date, but I can’t quite understand it. It’s positioned as being separate from .social, but its main admin is a generic name, there are two main admins from .social, and one other admin with zero public activity.

  • piefed.blahaj.zone runs on an older version of PieFed. One moderator of a flagship community on lemmy.blahaj.zone also moderates a community with a long history of brigading and harassment, so I’m not sure it’s a great choice.

And that’s it for the instances with at least 100 monthly users. Given that everything is federated, you’d think the per-instance user counts don’t matter, but my limited understanding of how federation works is that posts may not even be pulled if there aren’t enough users subscribing to the communities they originate from. Moreover, if an instance is not attracting enough users, I feel it is more likely to be closed down.

I could go over some of the others, but there’s some seemingly petty drama involving the next on the list, so it may be best not to.

Edit: Corrected one fact about feddit.online.

  • Rimu@piefed.socialM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    17
    ·
    4 days ago

    Local user numbers don’t really matter, as long as the instance has been around for a while (check the age in the instance chooser) and they’re keeping the software up to date.

    You need an instance that has defederated from hexbear, which most of them are except piefed.zip. Bad luck with that choice, sorry about that.

    You’re welcome on piefed.social, I can help you migrate the community. You’ll have those member numbers back up above 75 in no time, I’m sure.

    BTW feddit.online is run by Jerry, I’m just a fake admin on there to help out occasionally. Jerry runs a Mastodon instance as well, a pixelfed instance and more which is an extraordinary dedication to the fediverse cause. Jerry has been very keen on PieFed since the beginning so normally I’d heartily recommend feddit.online to you but with the topic of your community being what it is you’re going to attract a bit of heat and feddit.online is relatively wild west than piefed.social. On piefed.social I got your back tho.

    • Rose@piefed.socialOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      4 days ago

      You’re too nice and understanding. Making this even harder for me!

      On the user count part though, as I looked into migrating my communities, I saw that my new .ca account sees only the most recent posts in my .zip community, whereas my older piefed.social account subscribed to it for longer sees more. This is explained in the Move instructions, but that also suggested to me that user counts may play a role. I’ve seen the same problem on Mastodon: I’d sometimes need to first subscribe to an account to see its posts. Defederated instances and configurations being equal, is the All feed the same between a huge instance and a one-person instance for example?

      • Rimu@piefed.socialM
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        9
        ·
        4 days ago

        A huge instance will have a more complete All feed, yeah. But I found that when piefed.social was first launched, as soon as it had a dozen users between us we were already subscribed to 90% of the active communities on Lemmy. At 20+ users you’ll have 98% of them. (not exact numbers, just gut feel).

        Since then we’ve added 3 admin tools for mass-subscribing to communities to make getting a new instance widely federated even easier. I consider it a solved issue.

        The way Lemmy and PieFed federate is quite different to Mastodon so the isolated instance problems on Mastodon are very much reduced.

        • Rose@piefed.socialOP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          4 days ago

          Interesting, but then it seems weird that my two years old .zip community had only about 20 of its 200+ posts when I first subscribed to it from piefed.ca this week. It already had two local subscribers too.

          • Elting@piefed.social
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            4 days ago

            I noticed a bunch of posts missing from my comm when I visited it from lemmy.world but they seem to be there now.

            • Rose@piefed.socialOP
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              4 days ago

              For my community, it’s the same number as yesterday or probably the day I subscribed and I don’t think the count has gone up except when I manually retrieved them with the respective PieFed feature.

  • Shadow@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    edit-2
    4 days ago

    You haven’t been able to reach us? How did you try? What’s up?

    Dming support@lemmy.ca will get you the fastest response, rather than pinging us directly on piefed.

    I don’t think rimu does release notifications anywhere, so i just upgrade it when I remember. If you ever want piefed.ca upgraded, you can just poke me and it’s easy for me to do

    • Rose@piefed.socialOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      4 days ago

      Glad to know you’re around, even if that’s not particularly obvious! I saw that smorks has no public activity, while you and mp3 were last active on PieFed months ago, so I contacted the two admins who were recently active on PieFed: Recursive (via Matrix, as my new .ca account was restricted from DMing) and Otter (from this account, after receiving no reply from Recursive).

      The reason I avoided anything that looked like a global mail system that potentially goes to everyone is that when push comes to shove, it’s rare that all admins have equal say, so I wanted to get to the current lead admin to ask them my questions that could help decide whether the instance is the right fit for me. I may DM you now that you’re here!

      • Shadow@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        7
        ·
        4 days ago

        Support goes to a group chat so we all see it, but welcome to dm me. Support will usually be fastest though.

      • Otter@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        4 days ago

        Hi Rose, just coming across this post now. I did reply to the message, but in case it didn’t go through, I can also send the reply to a different account. Would it be ok to send it to this one?

        • Rose@piefed.socialOP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          3 days ago

          Hi, it appears that piefed.social’s default settings disallow messages from remote instances. From my testing after your comment, I established that my messages do go through, but messages from others do not until I change that setting. It’s now set to anyone, so feel free to re-send the message to this account just so it doesn’t get lost. I’ve also submitted a feature request to PieFed to make the setting state obvious to users who are about to send a message. It looks like that problem isn’t on you at all.

  • Vicinus@piefed.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    4 days ago

    As others have said, total active instance user numbers shouldn’t really matter. I believe fedinsfw.app is the only instance de-federated (though .social “silences” quokk.au, so you would miss out on .social user, if on quokk.au), so you really don’t need to worry about that.

    You can check out this weekly post, if you want to see data to help you choose from the top instances.

    “MAU - Difference (Piefed):” or “MAU - Change (%, Piefed):” can give you a rough idea if a specific instance has been growing, shrinking, or holding stable.

    I use “MAU/HYAU (%, Relative, >10 MAU)” (in the “Retention” tables) as a rough barometer of how well users like their instances. It measures how many half year active users have been active in the last month, relative to all the other Piefed instances that have been around the same amount of time.

    The fit isn’t great, so it shouldn’t really be used to compare instances with significantly different number of days being active/online, but works pretty well for similar start dates (“Server Active (Days)”). Positive is better, but generally I’d say just avoid anything heavily negative (for Piefed, worse than -25%).

    Let me know if you have any specific questions about the data and I can give you more info.

    Also, if you’re not aware, !fedigrow@lemmy.zip has some helpful links in the sidebar to help federate your moved groups to more instances (once you’ve moved them).

  • CombatWombat@feddit.online
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    4 days ago

    feddit.online has been great for me and I would recommend it. Also if your lemmy.zip account is a similar username, that would make feddit.online the power instance for soccer posting, which would be fun.

  • HubertManne@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    4 days ago

    thing is that .social is going to be the one that always is on the latest. I agree with others that users don’t matter as federation makes (theoretically) everything available. As long as your federated to the large instances their users should interact with the community same as if it was local to their instance.

  • Grail@multiverse.soulism.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    4 days ago

    Hi Rose! MULTIVERSE admin here! If your communities are the ones I see moderated by @rose@lemmy.zip, I’d be happy to help you make a home for them here. Big fan of the one that’s getting brigaded. We’re an anarchist instance with a rule against promoting authoritarianism, and we’ve defederated the tankie triad. Might be a good match. As for the bigger community, I think it would be a great addition to our instance as long as it’s not, like, a pro-capitalism pro-AI kind of community. Talking about free games and Tim Sweeney sounds like great fun!

    Only problem I can foresee as definitely being an issue for you is that dbzer0 has defederated us, so you won’t get traffic from that site.

    • Rose@piefed.socialOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      4 days ago

      Thanks. I’ll keep your instance in mind, and even if I go with another, things can go wrong, as they do. Hopefully never again, but there’s no way to predict the future. I’d want the admins of my instance to be hands off though, even if they absolutely disagree with what’s being posted (obvious things like hate speech aside, of course). Probably the only time I’d want them to step in is if I couldn’t solve a problem with mod tools.

      • Grail@multiverse.soulism.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        4 days ago

        Ah yeah this is an instance with opinionated administration, very far left. No worries, I hope you find a good home for your video games and investigative journalism!

  • OpenStars@discuss.online
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    4 days ago

    Fwiw, PieFed.zip really struggled with their last update but says that it is currently running v1.9.0-dev. (which is somehow a higher version than PieFed.social? I don’t have time to get into this right now but hopefully this observation helps point you in the right direction at least:-)

    • wjs018@piefed.wjs018.xyz
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      4 days ago

      .zip actually runs the development version of PieFed instead of the stable version that .social is running on. It sometimes means that things break for them, but it also means that they get early access to some features.