It’s worth pointing out that feeling like you work in a pointless, meaningless job doesn’t necessarily make it true. This paper is solely about people’s perceptions, not facts.
The opposite of that is also true - feeling like you’re doing something useful doesn’t make it so
Nothing highlights this as much when your management actually says and believes that “the purpose of our organization is to make money”. Totally clueless people.
No… the purpose is to deliver value to all stakeholders including customers, and society at large and by doing it well make some money. So it maters what you do and how you do it and the vision around it.
I mean, legally, that is the purpose of a for-profit company. From a policymaker’s perspective it has wider purposes, but to the managers that’s basically “not their job”
That is kind of my point exactly. The purpise of companies was not originally so. I is just a view heavily promoted by elites. Even the courts believe it now. Was not always so. Hence it does not always have to be so.
Yes, but what the alternative is isn’t so clear cut. Every corporation thinking through the impacts of their decisions on every other person in the world is obviously unfair (even governments have trouble tracking stuff), and even if they could how do you make them? Benevolent leadership is, if you look across history, a myth.
How do you allow a CEO to work against their shareholders without basically legalising embezzlement? You can’t write every possible scenario into your law, and shouldn’t ever try. How do you get random shareholders to care about a social issue, and how do you assure whatever social issue they pick is a good one and not “putting down the gays”? You could tear up the whole market system and start fresh but I’ve yet to see that done in convincing detail.
The solutions aren’t obvious. I do think they exist, but I’m trying to quit value judgements on the internet, so I won’t write a manifesto here.
PS on the history bit you mentioned, it seems to me a corporation is just an overgrown street peddler, and street peddlers have always been looking to make a profit. The occasions they don’t have been flukes.
Lol, this is why I left comp engineering to work in a nature preserve
I would LOVE to go back to the tree farm or become a park ranger or something. It just doesn’t pay the bills that my cloud engineering does.
Yeah! Hey in this economy, I regret it at times! In the world we live in, there are always trade-offs. No shame in whatever path you take, as long as you don’t vote Republican!
very happy i landed a job doing web work for mostly non profit clients. a few lawyers here and there, but we need them, too.
I’ve sort of just accepted it. I work in a niche position in a software company that’s in a niche sector and while people do depend on me for their livelyhoods, I wouldn’t say the products I produce are, in the grand scheme of things, meaningful. What I do only exists as a job in the 20th and 21st centuries and humans got on just fine before that.
I instead find meaning in my hobbies and out of work activities. My job, while pretty meaningless in my mind, does pay me enough to allow me to have a good life outside of work. I don’t need my job to be meaningful, I just need it to not suck.
