I am a fan of Arthurian legend and was about to start Taliesin, the first book of the Pendragon series by Steven Lawhead. But then I was reading some background and sounds like he recast a lot of the Arthur/Merlin legend in a Christian light? I’m atheist but not opposed to reading CS Lewis-style Christian allegory if it’s still interesting in a literary way. But not interested in backdoor Christian proselytizing. What do you all think? Worth a try or not?

  • IonAddis@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 year ago

    So, I haven’t fully re-read the series in over a decade.

    From what I remember, any religion was in-universe-accurate. It approches things from a historical standpoint, not religious. And in the time period those myths are set in, the people in Britain were in general converting from pagan cultures to ones with christian influence. The characters themselves practice a mix of pagan influence and christian ones.

    Like, the Britain in the series is one affected by the history of Roman colonization in the south, with more pagan influences the further from London you go. So characters that were a part of the roman legions are going to be more christianized, and ones that weren’t aren’t necessarily.

    Let’s say you picked up a semi-historical fantasy set in Japan. Historically, it’s accurate that any given character in such a book would practice one of the religions common in Japan in that period. It’s would be atypical in some regions in some eras for someone NOT to have some level of identification with the local religion.

    This series is like that. Yes, the influences of religion on the characters are present. Is it a thin-veiled attempt at preaching? No, not from what I recall. It’s possible modern discourse might have changed my viewpoint, as I mainly read this series pre-internet (late 90s, early 2000s), but I did not find religion in this series overbearing last I read it.

    I don’t remember many details from the series, but I remember vividly that one character, I THINK Merlin’s mother, was a pagan priestess bullrunner in her youth? From Atlantis? And I don’t remember her becoming a zealot christian or something. It’s possible she might have converted later in the books and I don’t recall as the culture of Atlantis gets diluted due to it being destroyed, but if she did it would have been in a more historical manner.

      • IonAddis@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        1 year ago

        The second book, Merlin, is one that has stuck with me in broad strokes decades later, and I want to re-read it. I loved his arc of going from favored son to wild man to mystic.

        Not all books stick with me like that.