

I’ve heard that Mao’s “On Contradiction” is quite helpful for that


I’ve heard that Mao’s “On Contradiction” is quite helpful for that


deleted by creator


As I see it arming is close to the last step, the sheer ammount of mass popularity necessary for the spark of crises to ignite, is far from what it’s been achieved in most of the west, for what I’ve seen we have a very theory oriented communist structure, that often only reaches academic circles while the most poor parts of society are more than likely written off as hopelessly brainwashed and seen as some sort of inconvenience, instead as the fundamental basis of dispute, if we keep only reaching some sectors of academic and middle class no matter how many weapons we have, no revolution will come out of it, untill we find the way to reach the people with respect and care, we are doomed to fail


Yeah we need to have a revolution as the goal but with the appropriate sense of priority of in what step we are in the road of revolution to care about the necessary basis for the revolution but without falling into a perpetual immobility that will never progress to revolution when the opportunity arrives
Just to be pedantic, the most accurate dynamic would be the bourgeoisie control the politicians and the police and the proletariat is indeed pretending to play, that one is correct


There are a couple of things that go against it, the fact that the counter revolutionary ideology caught on deeply in Russia, so the revolutionary forces there are not in good shape, there is the fact that the war staying as a success will bolster the status quo as successful, and further more the way the advanced weaponry affects the chance of revolution today is a lot more complicated, because the bourgeois state control a lot of surveillance and unmanned fire power makes staging a revolution a lot trickier. So I would not think a revolution is looking likely there, but it’s not impossible basically anywhere given the correct steps, is just a matter of how many are already done at any given time, and in Russia I see the need of many steps and I see few taken
And on a side note, I’m not fully convinced the west didn’t realize how powerful Russia was militarily, they act surprised, but I would wager they had an idea about it and that war us both a way to stress a bit their firepower, prevent them from helping others such as Iran or Venezuela with supplies, and probe for more information about that firepower


Its the collection selected works of Mao, tome 1, I don’t remember the section, but what he said was something like, people believed that where your ancestors were buried determined the luck of a person, and that was used to legitimize the local oppressive leadership rule. Then when they overthrew them Mao said something what happened did their ancestors changed graves? Did the gods changed their mind, no it is you that make your own destiny.
It was something clashing a bit with the uses of oppression of the religion but not mocking or ridicularized for being religious, and there is other one saying that is not our job to take religion out of people, that movement comes from the people if they see they do not need that belief anymore or if they come to see that they are being oppressed by religion, at any rate there is no rejection of religious people and it is quite clearly implied that a considerable number of the revolutionary force will be religious. So I will say there is a direction away from relegion on Marxism, there is no denying that, but from that should follow the rejection of a religious person, if your beliefs do not clash with revolution, and you do not preach during the actions of your organization, you can be at peace and keep your beliefs for as long as you see fit, your actions and your dedication for revolution is what matters


Those people that claim you cannot be religious and communist are missing the point and if you think about it reasonably kinda dooming the revolution in the global south, which is overwhelmingly religious, if you read the selected works of Mao in his speeches he would mobilize the religious beliefs of people, in a questioning manner but not as to attack the people but to challenge some parts of it, but that in itself shows that the people following Mao were religios at least part of them, and that was not a problem in itself, the exploitation that organized religion enacts on people is, so if your faith helps you go through life, and if you have your heart and mind in the idea of changing the world to one where there is si much less senseless suffering of people, my friend any Communist organization worth their salt would be lucky to have you, be a friend of the people and you’ll be a good Communist. Just some last points that i think are somewhat obvious for you but I would avoid using religious arguments into the agitation and propaganda campaigns if you end up on such tasks of an organization, even when talking to people that share your faith, once it might give the idea that the organization has religous bases or encourages religiosity, which I don’t think is usually the case, even if an organization has no problem with members being religious(which I think is the correct position) it wont be something reccomended
I’d point out the accessibility of food in particular, from under the non constraints, and add from another side, beating the Nazis in the great patriotic war aka WWII


My understanding is that it is impossible to tell right now, it would heavily depend on the revolutionary process of each country, the path to socialism is less of a recipe more of an improvisation like in jazz, you need to know the scales work well with your companions but what comes next is heavily dependent on what is going on right now, it’s really hard to have a one size fits all plan. Even in some quite basic stuff Lenin believed that revolutions would always start with the urban proletariat, while in China came from the farmers, because reality there was very different, and the world we live now is much more different from revolutionary China than revolutionary China was from revolutionary Russia, so the shape of a current time revolution ia expected to be different and to require modern adaptations of theory. Not yo say that the theory is obsolete, as some do its core its invaluable, but it needs to be adapted to the reality of each place
Yeah Brazil is ruled by a guy that cares about the people but does not dare to stand strong against the bankers and the big farms, so it did a lot of questionable choices in order to appease them, not what I’d call a bad guy but someone not willing to fight, it’s not out of cowardice either the guy faced jail when people plotted against him, he just avoids conflict and that leads to that meme of meeting in the middle with the right


I thought the fact that he had been shot a few times before was a very relevant factor for that


Could anyone explain?


Ever is a very long time so hard to tell, but given the difficulties of forming and maintaining a communist party inside most countries, be them Arab or not, I have a hard time seeing this happening in the absence of a very impactful event that empowers some communist organizations in the region, and to be fair impactful things are happening quite frequently lately so who knows, but the current tendency as I see it, and I’m quite far from a geo politics specialist, much less specifically of the Arab region, I think the tendency is not leading to that direction


In my mind thinking about it like this is a mistake, when a revolution will happen is in many ways unpredictable, but if there is no group working for it, pouring their heart and soul to make it more likely day by day, it is impossible, so we should work for it as hard as we can without much concern for when will it happen we need to work to make the if it will happen a certainty
Yeah I think we are in agreement comrade, I just like to point out this things when I see a post on the subject because I’ve seen far too much people associate any attempt of improving the now (from the part of any socialist individual or organization) with a commitment with a inherently reformist agenda, so I like to leave the more expanded idea when I see a short communication about it, just to promote the broader vision a little
Easy there it’s not correct to say it is nothing but a distraction, if you make it the focus of your project for sure, but however possible we should try to make the changes possible that would help the working class, but of course that does not mean to adhere to their program but it is important to look at what improvements can be achieved. But never celebrating these folks as heroes or celebrating as a magnificent win it is a small comfort but far from the cure, and can distract, but can bring about some degree of help, the important part is to know that however much help that is, it’s always woefully insufficient. But help should never be discarded completely, even if ultimately in many cases we refuse the instances of incrementalism it’s important to know that it comes with a cost, because much of the people who would benefit a little right now, cannot see the possibility of a revolution ever working, but they want some improvement, in such case being against incrementalism can have a very significant impact on gathering support of who we most need on our side.
So from what I understand of was a mutually beneficial agreement between a power hungry judge, Sergio Moro, that had already some experience with extortion of politicians in the banestado case if I’m not mistaken, and the US government that intended to weaken Brazil’s oil and building industries, to reduce the country self reliance. For that purpose they took advantage of the corruption that happened between the high ranks of those companies and the politicians (although PT was involved it was one of the parties with the least involvement) which was nothing out of the ordinary, but they took that as a springboard for a very complex chain of arrests, that involved a lot of coercion to implicate, often innocent, others, such coercion was often did through financial extortion, sometimes psychological torture, some cases physical torture, and a lot of blackmail, often done through traps such as parties filled with sex workers that would be recorded and used as black mail(and it is likely that Moro still have access to many of them resulting in quite some political power that helped him to get to governor right now) . The result of those arrests, that were notified to the media before they happened to maximize coverage, was the sever damage to the companies instead of fixing the corruption issue the operation dealt much more damage to those companies far beyond what the corruption could
And on top of that when a lot of those cases would be judged, most notoriously Lula’s one, they would bend or even break the law to put the case in Moro’s hands and he would actively cooperate with the prosecution, in Lula’s case the guy was called Deltan Dalagnol, as seen on the collection of messages leaked by the intercept, nicknamed vaza jato (vaza means leak so it’s a joke with the lava jato name).
I think that mostly cover it. It was indeed started as a opportunistic move, unclear if it started with US involvement or they just boosted Moro after he started. The type of corruption they looked in was of low stakes, well known and long running, to look into that would not require so much sophisticated methods and would result in not all that much