

How is rating each candidate on a scale of 0-5 harder than ranking them in some arbitrary order?
Because, as I said, ratings give wildly divergent sums.
While not every round of IRV gives exactly equal sums because of exhaustion, generally they’re close. Eyeballing the sum of multiple six digit values doesn’t obviously fail.
This isn’t true for ratings, by design. This means it doesn’t pass the underinformed vibe check, which is the second biggest requirement in a voting system behind “not cheating” (because to them it vibes as cheating, so to them it fails the cardinal rule).






IRV is better than plain voting. No one claims perfect.
Better is inherently worthwhile, because incremental improvement gets shit done. Purity testing just perpetuates bad outcomes for longer.