

There’s been at least 4-5 super-massive country-wide protests in the US, in the last decade. How much have things changed? At least how much have the elite even been shaken and made an effort to minimize squeezing the people? The answer is negative. Every single protest has not just failed to bring about one iota of change. They actually led to opposite effects:
-
Various organizations sheepdogging angry and desperate people back to the old political mechanisms
-
Protests have been highly infiltrated, to the extend where they die out from infighting and disorganization, or provocateurs and saboteurs.
-
Reactionaries becoming more and more inflamed and putting their own politicians in power, who are working precisely against what the protests wanted to achieve in the first place.
-
Reactionaries being used in establishment propaganda as a tool of fear, in order to herd protestors back in line to vote and back up the status quo again.
Literally, what is a protest? A protest is a WARNING AND A THREAT OF VIOLENCE. A protest is a show of force, a flex targeted at the elite and the rulers saying “You see how many of us are here? If we choose to come for you, you can’t stop us. So you better take notice and change course, or next time we are laying down the placards and the flags, and we are coming with fire and pitchforks”.
Every single protest that has ever worked, has either worked because the protest targets got SCARED(see Roosevelt’s reforms in the 30s, Nixon’s reforms in the 70s), or because it transitioned into a full-on VIOLENT REVOLUTION.
So when libs go about organizing their peaceful demonstrations and marches, the action is destined to fail, precisely because it is peaceful. US senators, and US congresspeople, and US presidents, and US billionaires, understand this very well, which is why their answer to protesting is to silently ignore them.
The US is just an example here. This applies all over the world. If peaceful protest worked, then judging by the scale of worldwide protests, by now Israel wouldn’t just have stopped bombing Gaza, it would have given Palestine its independence and then disarm itself.
When libs go on about how violence is bad, and doesn’t solve anything, it’s good to remember that the reason we even have a semblance of democracy worldwide right now, is because hundreds of thousands of French men and women got out in the streets, stormed the guardhouses and the gates, took the aristocrats out of their palaces, beat the crap out of them and then chopped their heads off in plain view. And while the French revolution didn’t go so well afterwards, what ended up happening is that the nobles of Europe got scared shitless that their own serfs would do the same to them, so they granted them constitutions and democratic processes.
It’s also good to remember that the reason we have universal healthcare systems, free public education, subsidized households, retirement funds, unions, worker rights and protections, is because hundreds of thousands of Russian men and women improved upon the example of the French, and not only overthrew the nobles, they also chained up the capitalists and put them to hard labour for all the evils they did upon them. The European capitalists got scared shitless, like their aristocratic cousins a century prior, and decided to ease off on squeezing every single penny out of every single pound, and tried to buy off the European proletariats by emulating some aspects of the Soviet experiment.
Yeah, it’s good to protest. It’s good to also remind ourselves that we are many and can achieve things. But protesting isn’t the end-game. The end-game is overthrowing the system that produces injustice. You can’t fix what is designed to be broken. Protesting is one tool we have, but it’s a middle-of-the-road tool. We should never lay down our capacity for violence, because by declaring our docility, we might as well proclaim our defeat.
It takes effort to make aliens actually feel alien, and then build a good story around them.
It’s far easier (and possibly more engaging for most people) to make aliens by exaggerating human characteristics, and then have a story about humans facing against their worst or best traits.