How can people be against capital punishment and then be pro torture? Either you are pro human rights or you’re not …
Who are these pro-torture anti-capital punishment people you are referring to?
I made them up. :)
you dropped your straw man outside
Except that this isn’t a straw man argument. Of course, nobody puts it quite so bluntly, but some people do in fact argue in this way. One can certainly debate what constitutes torture, but don’t pretend that there aren’t people who express violent fantasies about those they regard as deserving or undesirable to society.
some people do in fact argue this way
who?
Anyone who comments about rapists getting used as sex toys in prison, for one. Anyone who makes a drop-the-soap-joke. Anyone who supports texas not having climate controls in prison. To some extent, anyone who supports chain gangs or forced agricultural labor. The us constitution, and its writers, who said slavery was a suitable punishment for crime.
oh so it’s a us-only thing?
Nope, definitely a sentiment elsewhere
Death row inmates also cost way more than typical inmates. Mostly due to the trials being more involved, various appeals, and other legal costs.
I’m not saying cost should be the determining factor in how we handle criminal justice, I’ve just encountered a frustrating number of people who assume that putting sometime to death is cheaper than life imprisonment because “they aren’t around as long.”
For some reason whenever capital punishment comes up the arc is always guy 1 doesn’t support capital punishment (good), guy 2 does support it (bad) and guy 3 dosen’t support it (worse).
This is a problem born mostly of having a criminal “justice” system that is about institutionalizing retribution, mostly by subjecting them to traumatic horrors and the most dehumanizing things we could come up with.
If you have solutions other than torture them, killing them stops looking like a mercy. The torture isnt actually a neccisary option without alternatives.
Not trying to be a dick but necessary
How barbaric! Everyone knows that a quick nerve stapling and a long trip for them to the punishment sphere is what is needed
Gonna play devils advocate here: For something to be a punishment, you need to suffer in some way, and you can’t suffer if you’re dead in any way, so yeeting them into the void is more of a reward than a punishment, because you are basically freeing them of all suffering and consequences.
Like that’s one of the reasons I’m against the death penalty, it’s argument for it’s use as a punishment is predicated on the idea that there is a hell (no really), that being dead is going to mean eternal suffering, and basing a punishment on the supernatural is just silly. So you are either going to have to admit to one of two things:
- That a harsh life sentence full of misery and suffering is a better punishment because then the person experiences the punishment and the consequences of their actions.
- If we were going to have the death penalty, we would have to make it both so horrifically painful and so unspeakably long winded that even the most bloodthirsty would find it horrific, but we’ll get to that later.
All of the above isn’t even going into things like if the Death Penalty would even deter most murders as they are mainly spur of the moment things rather than movie style calculated moves in 90% of cases, and the 10% that are calculated serial killer things won’t be deterred because if you’re calculating your murder(s) to the point of carrying them out, I don’t think you’re in the right state of mind to be deterred by death either way.
And on top of that, most executions are carried out behind closed doors or in situations where viewing them is optional. Part of the reason why public executions were stopped in England was because they weren’t a deterrent for people, people were going to see them as Entertainment.
But let’s go back to Devil’s Advocate. Let’s say you are unconvinced by my arguments and believe the death penalty must be enforced. Here’s how I think we should do it if you genuinely are going to by into the idea that executions stop murders (stats say it doesn’t, but who’s counting).
First, we fit loudspeakers on top of high places, places that everyone, in the country and the city, would be able to hear. Church Towers, Minarets, Mobile phone masts, Radio towers, top of tower blocks, Wind Turbines, everywhere. Make sure nowhere is out of earshot.
Second, the method of Execution should be Immolu-cruxifiction, that is, being nailed to a cross, doused in petrol, and burnt alive. A fireproof oxygen mask and lines providing drugs to keep the condemned alive and conscious for as long as humanly possible. Inside the mask there’s a microphone to broadcast the screams.
Then, the execution. At a random time, sometime when most people are not at work or school, all TV channels and radio stations switch to a live broadcast of the execution, all internet traffic is redirected to a livestream of the execution, and the speakers play the radio broadcast live. If the TV has a method to be turned on remotely (like they have in Japan for Tsunami and Earthquake warnings), they are turned on. Then the execution happens. The condemned is nailed to a cross, their screams broadcast for all to hear, they are doused in petrol, and then they are raised up to the camera and set alight. The broadcast continues until the 60 seconds after the condemned is considered dead.
Oh, and murder will not be the only crime punished in this way, no no no. This can be brought in for any crime, but especially opposition to the death broadcasts.
That is the only way the Death Penalty will be a deterrent, if it’s forced in people’s faces, is as horrific as humanly possible, and carried out for even minor crimes.
TL;DR: The only way the Death Penalty would work in reality is if you do shit that would make ISIS horrified.
I reject your premise. Justice does not require punishment in the sense that someone has to experience it. Justice can mean preventing further harm by taking away someone’s freedom of action. Their agency. Be it a life sentence or death penalty they are no longer allowed to make choices about their life.
Again Justice can mean preventing further harm. The idea that someone has to suffer is just nonsense. That’s not Justice, that’s revenge.
I initially wanted to say something about the government’s role in punishing and something something socio-economics but then I read the rest of the comment and it doesn’t really fit the vibe I guess
When you’re pro-human wrong
To exist is to risk suffering, that’s why I, a REAL pro-human activist, am working to awaken cthulhu from his slumber so he can vanquish man from the face of the earth
It’s just the lesser of two evils
Ph’nglui mglw’nafh Cthulhu R’lyeh wgah’nagl fhtagn
Black Mirror
Pushing the throttle past Hammurabi to enable the afterburner: Christianity.

My exact reaction, when people actually think this way!
If the system wasn’t incredibly racially biased and so often absolutely wrong on the people it wanted to do capital punishment on, I might have less of an issue with it.
Like if there’s a literal psychopath (in the clinical sense) that was in no way ever able to change and would 100% constitute a threat in the outside world and you could 100% prove their guilt, okay sure I dont want my tax dollars paying for them to be alive anyway.
But that’s not how the system works and as long as there are potentially innocent people on death row who could continue to fight to prove their innocence, then I will be against capital punishment.
I’m also against the entire north american prison system though so.
“Psychopath” isn’t a clinical term, it’s a slang term for ASPD. And people with ASPD aren’t evil monsters, because psychiatry isn’t about judging people. Doctors aren’t priests.
A quick search reveals that the average time on death row in USA is 178 months or 14 years and 10 months. It’s not exactly an instantaneous thing.











