(404: Witty Comment Not Found)
Welcome to the Stubsack, your first port of call for learning fresh Awful you’ll near-instantly regret.
Any awful.systems sub may be subsneered in this subthread, techtakes or no.
If your sneer seems higher quality than you thought, feel free to cut’n’paste it into its own post — there’s no quota for posting and the bar really isn’t that high.
The post Xitter web has spawned soo many “esoteric” right wing freaks, but there’s no appropriate sneer-space for them. I’m talking redscare-ish, reality challenged “culture critics” who write about everything but understand nothing. I’m talking about reply-guys who make the same 6 tweets about the same 3 subjects. They’re inescapable at this point, yet I don’t see them mocked (as much as they should be)
Like, there was one dude a while back who insisted that women couldn’t be surgeons because they didn’t believe in the moon or in stars? I think each and every one of these guys is uniquely fucked up and if I can’t escape them, I would love to sneer at them.
(Credit and/or blame to David Gerard for starting this.)
You might all enjoy a little more awareness of the situation. As we all know, the easiest way to make 1.58 billion dollars is to start with 20.24 billion dollars.
That is impressive wonder how much money there was in doing a reverse his thing.
Scott got reposted on Naked Capitalism today re Unions
https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/ai-company-employees-should-unionize
If you’re interested, contact the people taking point on this, who I can vouch for as smart and trustworthy, at AIemployeeorganizing@gmail.com
Yeah nothing says trustworthy like a random Gmail posted on astral codex ten. who in hell is this, an eliezer alt?
What’s Naked Capitalism? Wasn’t the acx article some tongue-in-cheek bullshit where he essentially argued that unions suck and would make AI companies inefficient thus “moving timelines back” i.e. slow down the robopocalypse?
A shitton more outages have happened today
It appears that firing most of your human staff, replacing them with AI and then slashing funding to critical infrastructure has consequences. Like the insane amount of food recalls that happened this year, and all the measles outbreaks
Kinda interesting watching reddit go full conspiracy brained (honestly what’s wrong with usa liberals? There seems to be a strain that have never recovered from the paranoia of war on terror propaganda) about cyber attacks hitting high value targets like umm NASA network and an airline.
Surely the obvious explanation is we’re 4 years in to firing programmers, getting the remaining demoralised ones to shovel slop into things, and cutting constantly to make the line go up. The more networked everything is the more fragile it gets because we do networking wrong (I know, fighting words) and IT is a “cost center” so any time there appears to be an inch of slack it’s to the chopping block with staff and systems.
That’s my thoughts precisely. Neglecting food regulations gets tons of food recalls, neglecting health gets measles outbreaks and other outbreaks, thus neglecting tech gives us system failures. Plus all the funding for critical infrastructure has been slashed and people fired. It’s really not that surprising
I wonder how much of this could have been prevented if twitter had gone down after Musk hand moved the servers by just pulling them out of the racks.
In other news, the Computing As Social Activity has received public critique from OS-Sci (titled “Does Free/Libre Open Source need a conscience?”), which itself got a response (“CASA, conscience and the absence of constraint”).
For my unsolicited two cents on this convo, FLOSS abso-fucking-lutely needs some sort of ethical framework. We had an Emacs maintainer all-but endorse fucking slavery about two weeks ago, that’s evidence enough for me.
There are two ethical frameworks already here. The first framework is libertarian and focused on speech rights; the second framework is socialist and focused on anti-utilitarianism.
What I feel neither side is addressing is a useful side-effect of the first FLOSS framework. Suppose that:
- Software is free to everybody! Except for obviously-reprehensible Group X, of course.
- With time, Group Y comes to have many members who oppose some policy of the government.
- The government has declared: by definitional implication, all members of Group Y are also members of Group X.
The libertarians defend against this by demanding that we never withhold software from anybody at step (1). Socialists instead recognize this pattern as an issue with the government’s ability to censor and control resources, and instead demand that the government never carry out step (3). Our old alliance, with half-hearted socialists like RMS and anarchists like Moglen and gun-toting libertarians like ESR, only worked because this syllogism has two different points at which we can demand change. Capitalist liberals like Kühn only joined in later when it became clear that the movement could be co-opted for profit.
We are now currently faced with a slightly different situation:
- Software is free to everybody! Except for obviously-reprehensible Group X, of course.
- With time, Group X comes to control the government.
The libertarians now seem like enablers of Group X, don’t they! And worse, many of them, like ESR, explicitly are friends with lots of Group X folks and share many of their beliefs. Liberals don’t seem to understand that Group X exists? Socialists still can form alliances, but only to the degree that their allies are anti-Group-X and willing to fight against step (2). So FLOSS kind of falls apart, and we find ourselves using more and more Free Software written by tankies (like Lemmy!) since they now make up a larger proportion of socialists.
This is part of why I’m increasingly vocal about the economics of Free Software: (any particular piece of) software is a marginally-abundant good, so charging money for it is rent-seeking and we ought to subsidize its availability whenever it would create positive externality. This line of argument reveals new allies, like economically-literate/abundance liberals, anti-waste conservationists (Greens), and intellectual-property reformers (Pirates).
The critique was interesting in its legalistic focus. Basically an assumption that no one will be deterred from anything by anything but the threat of force. Capitalist realism in its most low-trust society version.
LWer: Twitter is a right-wing cesspool but that’s actually good for where else can I find people like Michael Tracey explaing to me that all women are sluts?
edit this particular LWer is being very disingenious here, he’s very right-wing but in that weird bloodless way that Rats love
This aged like fine milk
https://arjunpanickssery.substack.com/p/three-months-in-evaluating-three
Reddit has much more intense moderation and policing of non-mainstream views
Only because those views are also banned in Germany. ;)
Bluesky only exists because of Twitter’s current direction.
It’s amusing how singularly resilient so much commentary on Bluesky is to learning anything about its origins.
Most deranged, matter-of-face assertion I ever saw was that Bluesky was started by angry ex-twitter leftists who were ousted by Musk. You know, like Jack Dorsey.
Bluesky is a weird mix of trans catgirls and people who really really want to be functionaries for a centrist government or ‘journalists’ at a center-right paper like the NYT.
in defense you need to be Very Online to remember that Bluesky was inardventedly seeded with blue-haired LGBTQ+ folks long before Musk purchased Twitter.
Dorsey wanted to build the Nazi bar but was too late to market.
Bsky also used to have a lot more porn and sex workers.
And the fact that Jack Dorsey wanted to build the Nazi bar explains a lot of the design decisions in ATProto that don’t otherwise make a whole lot of sense.
Don’t you just adore how slopfondlers feel free rein to send people’s personal photos directly to massive corporations that make no promises of privacy and definitely won’t be compelled to sell it all off in the near future
Ooh, I like ‘slopfondlers’! Covers both slopmongers and slopmunchers.
And even if they make promises, it is clear they will not be held to account so there is no reason for them to follow the law.
The money authors were supposed to get still has not arrived, and it seems the system to get it also is “buggy” (I think not bugs but intentionally bad to discourage people, like getting an insurance payout, or contacting helpdesk because your device broke), and doesnt apply to people who didnt register their works with the us copyright thing (which isn’t a requirement to get copyright).
If all authors get treated like that, individual users who have their images abused have no chance.
Another Jacob Coxon interview has dropped and it is noticeably worse than the previous
To save 40 seconds of listening to this dingleberry
“But it’s like, it’s nice money, like I like it. It is—”
“But you could take the moral high ground.”
“Yeah, I could, I could, um”
“But you’re not.”
“I’m not, no.”
“Why not?”
“I like money bruh, I’m like… it’s, I agree it’s blood money, um…”
“Do you prefer dying to liking money?”
“I don’t think it’s gonna, if I thought for a moment that donating it, like, would change anything, then sure I’d do it, I also like—”
“Might give you more moral credibility, though.”
“I agree but you could also stop asking the question.”
“Because it’s irritating to be asked?”
“No but like uh, you know there’s, that would also, if you hadn’t asked it then the moral credibility wouldn’t have been… questioned. Um, anyway…”media training of a rotten stump
Haha remember when people took this guy seriously for like a day lmao
I wonder whether “I don’t think it’s gonna” was a slip that he was going to continue with “kill everyone”, until he remembered at the last moment why he was even sitting there with any publicity whatsoever.
Used to be that grifters had to be at least a little good at the con. Yet another sign of the bubble bursting lol
he initiated a preference cascade!
edit this was the preferred term used on LW to describe the short 15 minutes of fame enjoyed by AI safety when Coxon first appeared.
For some reason, now there’s a Democratic congressional majority who doesn’t seem to emamored with AI they’re much less optimistic.
he initiated a preference cascade!
much like eating too much Taco Bell causes a, uh, another kind of cascade
Ahh, classic LW minting a needlessly technical-sounding term for something that already exists, in this case nudge theory
also: I don’t expect the democrats to meaningfully use their momentum
Look at this extremely offended dork
Tankie sloperator Yogthos ripped off Jank, a Clojure dialect, to produce a vibecoded thing called Jolt. The orange site isn’t impressed, with Jank’s author pointing out some design issues diplomatically coded as “differences” and Ol’ Yoggie unleashing personal attacks on anybody who dares to question their brilliance and competence. Previously on Lobsters, Yoggie isn’t happy about Lobsters’ new policy which allows his
slopamazing Clojure work to be flagged as spam. (Dear Yog, if you’re hate-reading, I want you to know that I never flag on Lobsters; this is 100% organic community flagging from ordinary lurkers.)Tankie sloperator Yogthos ripped off Jank, a Clojure dialect, to produce a vibecoded thing called Jolt.
This is the first time letters have been arranged in this sequence since the dawn of humanity.
deleted by creator
Can a superintelligent chatbot play Minecraft as well as a tween? Somebody allowed chatbots to play Minecraft Skyblock, a popular mod which forces players to incrementally reinvent the tech tree with scarce resources. Choice sneer: after Grok’s avatar gets itself stuck in a wall and dies, it complains in chat, “Wall’s rigged. Physics cheated. Void’s rigged.” It dies from wall-stuckness four times in that scene alone.
some thoughts
The bots are not skilled, so the editor had to intervene multiple times. They try to build towers; you’ll have to see for yourself how poor their artistic sensibilities are. Interestingly, there’s an advertisement partway through for some preskilled bots, and I think that this gives away the entire magic trick: if a bot is equipped with e.g. a skill for generating cobblestone then it will not take multiple days and interventions to invoke the skill and build the generator, and the advertisement is merely a sequence of demonstrations of skills. Of course, it wouldn’t be a chatbot video without a prisoner’s dilemma where the bots press some buttons to choose their destiny and fail basic game theory. Honestly, I would completely understand if I’ve eaten the onion here, as the bots are so comedic and stereotypical as to possibly be human-written, although I think it’s just good editing.
To refresh the palate after that, consider Summoning Salt’s recent video on the history of Minecraft speedrunning records.
it complains in chat, “Wall’s rigged. Physics cheated. Void’s rigged.”
Ow god… AI has replaced my gaming skills.
PC Gamer dumps on Ashes of the Singularity 2 for being chock-full of slop: https://www.pcgamer.com/games/rts/ashes-of-the-singularity-2-review/
Yet another Stardock-published game that was all too eager to embrace GenAI in the development process. I gave Sins of a Solar Empire 2 a pass on the strength and long support tail of the previous game, as well as the developers swearing up and down that the obvious bits of AI art were placeholders, but some people didn’t. It’s got a campaign DLC coming, the first in the series, so here’s hoping they are paying attention and do better than this:
It doesn’t help that the story is dreadful—a three way philosophy and ethics lecture between humans, AI, and uploaded post-human personality constructs. It’s a parade of characters you never actually see babbling endlessly about the vague machinations of AI threats and whether or not post-humans are still the same people they were when they were bags of flesh and juice.
Ironically, the story is also where Oxide’s use of generative AI is most evident… Frankly, I’m skeptical that this represents the limit of Oxide’s AI use. All the character portraits look straight up AI generated to me, and the voice lines sound similarly infected. AI or not, it’s something of a moot point because, either way, they’re both awful. The portraits have that horrible, plasticky AI sheen to them, while the acting is often weirdly intoned in a way that does not help the narrative’s bamboozling quality.
[Command & Conquer]'s FMVs aren’t remembered because they’re expensive, or even especially great storytelling. They’re remembered because they’re fun, silly, intensely human creations. You don’t need a massive budget to replicate that. If Oxide Games stuck a beret on a programmer and had them ham it up in front of the camera, the result would be infinitely preferable to Ashes 2’s airy, inhuman waffle.
This should be nailed on the doors of a church.
Hell, that’s literally how we got Max Payne and by extension all of Remedy’s catalog
mmm yes, let’s add to the pile of Congressional subpoenas this corporation will be receiving, said no institutional investor ever
The guy who willingly resigned? What changed his mind?
a legion of techbros offering to fellate him
After all the fun last week this one is going to be a bit of a downer isnt it?
I mean we still have Anthropic’s IPO
I’m a bit over the whole ‘a fool and his money’ bit tbh.
How would that work, technically? (the link doesn’t finish loading for me)
I guess the simplest way would be for the majority shareholders to appoint a new board.
Would they even need to since he stepped down rather than being dismissed? I imagine that the current board is looking at the trade restrictions inquiries and wondering if they can bring back the gravy train that Jensen appeared to have been driving.
Gary Marcus declares the bubble burst… Again…
Pulling some stuff out of the comments:
”Well, if the Anthropic and OpenAI pull in investors the way SpaceX did, this could be a path to reducing wealth inequality that is faster and less controversial than taxing the rich. SpaceX peaked at 226 in June. Now it is 136.”
I have no fucking clue what this is supposed to mean. Is it more ‘AGI will give us UBI’ bs or are they suggesting that the reduction of wealth inequality will be the rich loosing their cash from a bubble burst?
“Less than four years ago Nvidia was $15 a share. After all of the crashing so far it is $150 a share. People today are paying $150 for it. The bubble will burst, but a lot of folks still seem enamored with tulips. Trump, who still has almost two months of relatively free reign, called for reinstating Huang as Nvidia CEO. Whether he will get behind Anthropic is harder to say, unless Amodei proves to be having an affair.”
I mean Trump also wanted Tim Cook to be the Nvidia CEO so I think he’s just saying whatever. A lot of folks are enamoured with the tulips, but more are also becoming skeptical of this business model. And those tech stocks won’t stay up forever if Nvidia keeps falling.
are they suggesting that the reduction of wealth inequality will be the rich loosing their cash from a bubble burst?
This was my read but they are forgetting that when SPCX went public, many pension funds and index funds used as vehicles for investment by retail investors/everyday folks that lost wealth. The VC and PE investors would have got out when the value started tanking and probably made a profit.
But also, if the valuation plummets and a billion ““dollars”” are erased from the market cap, there’s no billion dollars that magically appears in the hands of normal people.
Yeah exactly. They’re left holding the bag with their pension fund… Oh well it’s not like we’ll need pensions whereas it would be cruel to deprive Mr Musk of that extra half trillion (/s should be self evident but I’ll add it anyway)

from r/linux: twitter exchange with grapheneOS
tweet exchange text
GrapheneOS:
We understand the code a lot more than before. Bear in mind we didn’t write the vast majority of the code and we have substantially higher quality standards than Google. We now have tools to help understand and work with millions of lines of human slop like the Linux kernel.
Bilskirnir3124:
> human slop
Wild turn of phrase my guy.GrapheneOS:
You can’t blame LLMs for the incredibly insecure and buggy status quo of large mainstream software, firmware and hardware projects. Linux has hundreds of of preexisting severe vulnerabilities being found and fixed every month. Linux already churned out endless slop without LLMs.
GrapheneOS:
Projects can now churn out slop even faster with LLMs but they didn’t need them to do it. This was already the status quo for software at large. Being able to so easily find bugs is creating massive pressure to finally use better tools and approaches to create robust software.
On the one hand they have a point that slop is not restricted to LLMs. on the other hand, fuck off with this wishy washy bullshit. Do they hear themselves? Automating slop is objectively bad and it has been clear for a long while now that all of these “bugs found” numbers are insane overestimations(read: lies) and any that are found are basically just a result of throwing endless resources at a problem until it stops moving
“hey look we know that everyone else who uses AI shits the bed but they weren’t holding it right. We know how to hold it right” nods assuredly
While nodding, their head is repeatedly impaled on the large spikes of the thing they’re holding.
i guess i gotta commit to my lightphone. Why do these guys want a cookie for demonstrating their contempt for craftsmanship?
My mind went to martial arts analogies for some reason, but the best one that bubbled up is, “This is Wimp Lo. We trained him wrong, as a joke”







